Friday, March 24, 2023

Reply of Notice / Consumer Dispute / Consumer / Consumer Protection Act 2019

 

Ref.: RND / Legal / 3108-1907 / 22          Dated : 24th day of August’ 2022.

 

WITHOUT PREJUDICE

To,

Suvendu Das, Advocate,

Alipore Judges’ Court Bar Liabrary Room No. 2, 18, Judges’ Court Road, Kolkata – 700027.

 

Residence & Chamber :

 

Suvendu Das, Advocate,

Flat No. S-2, 2nd Floor, 23/1, Banamali Naskar Road, Police Station – Parnasree, Kolkata – 700060. Mobile : 9836586307.

 

Ref.: your Letter dated 01/08/2022.

 

Reg. : Self-contained residential unit ( Tiles flooring) being Flat No. “C” consisting 2 bed rooms, 1 kitchen cum dinning, 1 topilet, 1 balcony, etc. on the Ground Floor ( western Side ) having an area 650 Sq, ft. ( Six hundred Fifty Square feet ) more or less ( Super Built up area ) of the building lying or situate at Premises No. 65/2, Jainuddin Mistry Lane, Post Office Alipore, Police Station Chetla, Kolkata – 700027, within local limits of Ward No. 082 of the Kolkata Municipal Corporation, registered in favour of Smt. Mohua Shome, daughter of Late Nayan Ranjan Shome, residing at Flat no. 2, 1st Floor, at Premises No. 33/C, Jainuddin Mistry Lane, Post Office – Alipore, Police Station – Chetla, Kolkata – 700027, through Deed of Sale being No. 160102582 for the year 2021, in Book I, Volume no. 1601-2021, Pages from 126522 to 126553, registered at the office of the District Sub Registrar – I, South 24 Parganas, Alipore, Kolkata - 700027.

 

Your Client : Smt. Mohua Shome, Daughter of Late Nayan Ranjan Shome, residing at Flat No. 2, 1st Floor, 33/C, Jainuddin Mistri Lane, Post Office – Alipore, Police Station – Chetla, Kolkata – 700027.

 

My Client : Ashok Kumar Gupta, Son of Late Girija Prasad Gupta, residing at Premises being no. 15, Mallick Para Lane, Post Office Bangur Avenue, Police Station Dumdum, Kolkata – 700055, District 24 Parganas ( North).

Dear Sir/s,

 

Under instructions and on behalf of my client Ashok Kumar Gupta, Son of Late Girija Prasad Gupta, residing at Premises being no. 15, Mallick Para Lane, Post Office Bangur Avenue, Police Station Dumdum, Kolkata – 700055, District 24 Parganas ( North), West Bengal, I serve upon you the following notice :

 

1)   That my client is in receipt of your above referred letter dated 01/08/2022. The said letter has delivered on 3rd day of August’ 2022, in evening to my client by the postal peon. My client astonished on bare perusal of your said purported letter dated 01/08/2022. The contents and purports of the said letter dated 01/08/2022 are not in consonance with any facts with either party, so far.

 

 

2)   That my client handover the said purported letter dated 01/08/2022, with specific instructions to reply as under in the followings ;

 

a)    The allegations in the said purported letter dated 01/08/2022, are all false, baseless, and concocted against my client, and thus those are not acceptable at any terms, so far.

 

b)   Your client raised three issues as the disputes relates to the measurement of flat, possession letter, and completion certificate. My client is ready and willing to resolve such issues one by one. Hence at the first threshold it is desirable to arrange your Surveyor Engineer by fixing a date for measurement of the said subjected flat and by the time my client also arrange a surveyor engineer and thus in presence of both the parties and their surveyor engineer the measurement of the said subjected flat will measure and report of those surveyor engineer will consider in respect of the measurement of the said subjected flat. In the event measurement of flat will find lesser than in the Sale deed then in such event the consideration value will reconsider and will pay back to your client. Further, in the event measurement of flat will find higher than in the sale deed then in such event the consideration value will reconsider and your client will pay for the higher measurement to my client. The possession letter is ready to give to your client, however in given situation as raised by your client the same will be given to your client after conclusion of the measurement of the subjected flat. It is pertinent to states that your client is in possession of the subjected flat as the same has been handed over to your client on the day of execution and registration of the Deed of Sale and consequently she, started work of interior decoration of her said flat, thus she is in possession of the subjected Flat. Regarding the Completion Certificate, my client had already applied for the Completion Certificate with the concerned authority of the Kolkata Municipal Corporation, and the same will be available within a period expected after 30 (thirty) days, so far thus as soon as the CC will be in hand the authenticated copy of CC will be provide to your client.

 

 

3)   My client all along co-operated your client and thus delivered the subjected flat at the desire of your client at the agreed consideration value thereof. Thus there is no cause has ever been arose on any deficiency in services and or unfair trade practices.

 

I for and on behalf of my client requesting you to advise your client to arrange your Surveyor Engineer by fixing a date for measurement of the said subjected flat and by the time my client also arrange a surveyor engineer and thus in presence of both the parties and their surveyor engineer the measurement of the said subjected flat will measure and report of those surveyor engineer will consider in respect of the measurement of the said subjected flat. In the event measurement of flat will find lesser than in the Sale deed then in such event the consideration value will reconsider and will pay back to your client. Further, in the event measurement of flat will find higher than in the sale deed then in such event the consideration value will reconsider and your client will pay for the higher measurement to my client. Kindly give a date for measurement of the said subjected flat, well in advance of seven days a week, so far. Communicate at the earliest to my client preferably within a period of fortnight from the date of receipt of this letter with you.

 

Kindly do the needful, in arranging for the measurement of the subjected flat, as such disputes has been raised by your client and such arrangement is necessary to resolve such disputes at the first threshold.

 

Thanking you,

 

Yours’ faithfully,

 

 

Rabindra Nath Das,

Advocate

High Court Calcutta

 

 

 

Copy to ;

 

Smt. Mohua Shome, Daughter of Late Nayan Ranjan Shome, residing at Flat No. 2, 1st Floor, 33/C, Jainuddin Mistri Lane, Post Office – Alipore, Police Station – Chetla, Kolkata – 700027.

 

{for information & necessary action to resolve disputes raised by you }

 

No comments:

Post a Comment