Saturday, November 14, 2026

Questions Raised Again over Public Prosecutor’s ‘Lapse’

 Questions Raised Again over Public Prosecutor’s ‘Lapse’

Sumit’s bail application is also pending before the High Court. However, it is alleged that his lawyers did not disclose this during the hearing before the lower court. His lawyers sought bail by submitting a written affidavit stating that all evidence in the case had been seized.

Subhasish Ghatak
Last updated: 15 November 2026, 08:38 a.m.

Sumit Roy. — File photograph.

The presiding judge reprimanded the lawyer representing Sumit Roy, a close aide to Diamond Harbour MP Abhishek Banerjee, over an alleged attempt to obtain bail by withholding information. Allegations of negligence have also been raised against the public prosecutor. Sumit, who was in police custody in connection with a soil theft case registered at Kalitala Ashuti Police Station, was produced before the Additional Judicial Magistrate (Bengal) at Alipore on Thursday. The judge was compelled to issue two orders in the same case because the accused’s lawyer had withheld information.

Sumit’s bail application is also pending before the High Court. However, it is alleged that his lawyers did not disclose this during the hearing before the lower court. His lawyers applied for bail by submitting a written affidavit stating that all evidence in the case had been seized. The public prosecutor and the complainant’s lawyer opposed the application. After examining the case diary and investigation records, the judge rejected the bail application and issued a written order.

Subsequently, however, the judge learnt that the matter was already pending before the High Court. Expressing displeasure, the judge observed that the hearing had been unnecessary in those circumstances. In the second order, the judge wrote: “Since the accused has applied for bail before the higher court, no hearing has taken place in the matter. The accused is remanded to judicial custody for 14 days.”

According to a section of lawyers, the accused’s lawyers had adopted a strategy to secure bail through unlawful means. The public prosecutor, too, failed to take note of the matter and did not inform the judge. An embarrassing situation was avoided because the judge discovered the information in time.

Meanwhile, on Thursday, the Special Public Prosecutor was absent on grounds of illness from hearings in three cases involving Trinamool Congress MLA Dilip Mondal and the other accused before the District Judge at Alipore. A section of lawyers at Alipore Court alleged that, although the Chief Special Public Prosecutor was seen on the court premises, he stayed away from the hearings in a somewhat “mysterious” manner.

Following the hearings, the District Judge was expected to direct which subordinate court would conduct the trials in the cases involving Dilip Mondal and the others. State police officials had recommended that the trials proceed while the Trinamool MLA and the other accused remained in judicial custody. However, owing to the absence of the public prosecutors, the judge fixed another date.

According to sources, the High Court is scheduled to hear the bail applications of Dilip Mondal and the other accused next week. A section of lawyers said that, if the High Court grants them bail, it would no longer be possible to conduct the trials while keeping them in custody. Questions have therefore begun to arise over the absence of the Special Public Prosecutor and the Chief Special Public Prosecutor from these important hearings.

A state police official also said: “Because of repeated negligence by public prosecutors in important cases, opportunities to conduct trials while keeping the previous government’s corrupt leaders and ministers in custody are being lost.”

About a week earlier, allegations of “negligence” by the public prosecutor had also arisen after former Trinamool MLA Saokat Molla obtained bail in two important cases.

(This report has been reproduced from the print edition of Anandabazar Patrika.)


No comments:

Post a Comment