Sunday, November 15, 2026

Read the public mood carefully. Respect people’s faith. Prepare thoroughly—and play each ball on its merit.

 In my view, whenever the Congress allows its political messaging to be perceived as an attack on Hindu beliefs, traditions or identity, it risks accelerating the erosion of its own public support. A party seeking to represent a diverse country must understand the emotional and spiritual significance that faith holds for millions of citizens. Criticism of a government, a political organisation or a particular policy is entirely legitimate. But political arguments lose their purpose when their language appears to ridicule the religious convictions of ordinary people. A national party must exercise the judgment necessary to keep that distinction clear.

The Congress faces a difficult political challenge: it must retain its existing supporters while persuading others that it offers a credible alternative. Yet any attempt to attract one section of society through language that alienates another can become self-defeating. Every community deserves dignity, security and equal opportunity. A party can advocate those principles with confidence while showing respect for Hindu traditions and the traditions of other faiths. When its public messaging fails to convey that balance, it creates doubts about its intentions and gives its opponents an opportunity to question its credibility.

That is why I believe the Congress must examine the political cost of its own rhetoric. Leaders may intend a statement for a particular audience, but its consequences extend far beyond the meeting or platform where it is delivered. Citizens elsewhere hear it, interpret it and remember it. Explanations issued afterwards may struggle to repair the original impression. Political communication requires an understanding of the country’s social and cultural sensitivities, together with the discipline to speak responsibly.

The difficulty for the Congress leadership, as I see it, is its continuing struggle to develop a persuasive democratic challenge to Shri Narendra Modi. Such a challenge requires a coherent account of what the party would do, how it would govern and why people should trust its leadership. Criticism must be supported by preparation, credible alternatives and sustained engagement with voters. Seniority and experience are valuable only when they help a party recognise changing public expectations and respond effectively.

The cricketing comparison captures this challenge well: Mr. Modi appears to approach the contest ball by ball, while the Congress too often seems absorbed in calculations drawn on a blackboard. A batsman must read the delivery actually coming towards him. He must observe the bowler, the field, the pitch and the demands of the moment. Preparation helps him, but he must still make a sound decision at the crease. In politics, too, strategy succeeds when leaders remain attentive to people’s immediate concerns and adjust their approach as circumstances change.

Blackboard calculations have their place. Electoral arithmetic, alliances and assessments of voting patterns are necessary parts of political planning. Their usefulness, however, depends on whether they reflect the lives and choices of real people. A voter cannot be understood entirely through a category or a numerical projection. The same citizen may care deeply about employment, prices, welfare, religious dignity, national security and the credibility of a local candidate. A strategy that overlooks this complexity can look convincing in a meeting room and prove inadequate at the polling booth.

To my mind, one of Mr. Modi’s political strengths is his ability to connect his message with the aspirations and cultural sentiments of many supporters. Any opposition seeking to challenge him must study that connection seriously. It must listen to what voters value, examine its own weaknesses and develop leaders who can earn confidence through consistent work. Dismissing the electorate’s convictions or repeatedly questioning its judgment will only make that task harder.

The Congress still has choices. It can build credibility through the performance of its governments, strengthen its organisation, encourage capable leadership and present carefully developed policies. It can challenge the government firmly while respecting the faith of citizens. It can seek support across communities through fairness and public service. These choices demand patient work and internal accountability, but they offer a more durable foundation for political recovery.

My concern is that every avoidable controversy over Hindu beliefs can draw the Congress further away from that work. If its leadership continues to underestimate the hurt such messaging may cause, it risks paying an increasing political price. The responsibility to prevent that outcome rests with the party itself.

India deserves a vigorous democratic contest in which parties earn support through sound ideas, competent governance and respect for the people. For the Congress, the essential task is to understand the country it seeks to lead and demonstrate that understanding through its words and actions. The electorate will make its own judgment.

Read the public mood carefully. Respect people’s faith. Prepare thoroughly—and play each ball on its merit.

Joy MAA.

Ashok Kumar Singh
Advocate, High Court Calcutta

No comments:

Post a Comment