When a Signed Cheque Is Dishonoured
The Presumption Under Section 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881
Once the execution of a cheque is admitted or proved, Section 139 requires the court to presume that the holder received it towards payment, wholly or partly, of a legally enforceable debt or other liability. Thus, where the cheque and the drawer’s signature are undisputed, the holder has the benefit of a statutory presumption about why the cheque was issued. In Rangappa v. Sri Mohan, (2010) 11 SCC 441, the Supreme Court clarified that this presumption extends to the very existence of a legally enforceable debt or liability.
How the burden shifts
Sections 118(a) and 139 operate together. Section 118(a) raises a presumption of consideration for the negotiable instrument. Section 139 specifically presumes that the holder received the cheque towards discharge of a debt or liability. In Kalamani Tex v. P. Balasubramanian, (2021) 5 SCC 283, the Supreme Court explained that once the signature is established, the evidentiary burden shifts to the accused. The court must therefore give effect to the presumption when it evaluates the complainant’s evidence and any explanation offered by the drawer.
How the drawer can rebut the presumption
The drawer can rebut the presumption by raising a probable defence on a preponderance of probabilities. In practical terms, the court considers whether the material on record makes the absence of the alleged debt or liability reasonably probable. A bare denial ordinarily falls short. In Basalingappa v. Mudibasappa, (2019) 5 SCC 418, the Supreme Court explained that the accused may rely on documents, surrounding circumstances, admissions elicited in cross-examination, or even the complainant’s own evidence. The accused may therefore rebut the presumption without entering the witness box. If the presumption is rebutted, the complainant must establish the alleged liability on the evidence.
Consider a trader who issues a cheque for an outstanding invoice. If the trader admits signing and handing over the cheque, the court starts with the presumption that it was issued towards payment. If the trader produces a bank transfer record and a receipt identifying the same invoice as already paid in full before the cheque was presented, those documents may support a probable defence. The court would examine whether the payment actually related to the liability represented by the cheque. The strength of that link matters more than a general assertion that the parties had other transactions.
What if the drawer signed a blank cheque?
Where a drawer voluntarily signs and hands over a blank cheque towards payment, the fact that the payee or another person later filled in its particulars does not by itself rebut the presumption. In Oriental Bank of Commerce v. Prabodh Kumar Tewari, Criminal Appeal No. 1260 of 2022, decided on 16 August 2022, the Supreme Court explained that the identity of the person who filled in the cheque was immaterial in the circumstances before it. Evidence about the circumstances in which the cheque came into the holder’s possession, or about whether any enforceable liability existed, can still be material.
What the complainant must still establish under Section 138
Section 139 addresses the purpose for which the cheque was received. A complaint under Section 138 must also satisfy the other statutory requirements. These include presentation within the applicable validity period, dishonour attracting Section 138, a written demand for payment of the cheque amount within 30 days of receiving information of dishonour from the bank, and the drawer’s failure to pay within 15 days of receiving the notice. Under Section 142, the payee or holder in due course must ordinarily file the complaint within one month from the date the cause of action arises. The court may take cognizance of a delayed complaint if sufficient cause for the delay is shown.
In a cheque dishonour trial, the court should therefore begin by deciding whether the cheque’s execution is admitted or proved, give effect to the statutory presumption, and then assess the drawer’s defence on the entire record. The complainant’s transaction records and the drawer’s explanation of why the cheque was issued can become decisive once the defence raises a genuine evidentiary issue about the underlying liability.
No comments:
Post a Comment