under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC), a proprietorship firm is not considered a “person” in its own right. However, this does not mean that a proprietorship business cannot invoke the IBC. Here's a clearer legal explanation:
📘 Legal Definition of “Person” under IBC:
Section 3(23) of the IBC defines “person” to include:
-
An individual,
-
A Hindu Undivided Family (HUF),
-
A company,
-
A trust,
-
A partnership firm,
-
A limited liability partnership (LLP),
-
Any other entity established under a statute.
❌ Notably, it does not mention "proprietorship firm" — because a proprietorship is not a separate legal entity.
✅ Then How Can a Proprietorship File under IBC?
A proprietorship firm operates in the name of its proprietor. Therefore:
-
The proprietor, as an individual, is a "person" under IBC.
-
He/she can initiate proceedings (such as under Section 9 for operational creditors) in their personal capacity, trading as the firm.
✔ Correct Style of Filing:
“Mr. X, sole proprietor of M/s ABC Enterprises”
🧑⚖️ Judicial Precedent:
-
M/s. Shailesh Sangani v. Joel Cardoso (NCLAT, 2019):
The NCLAT held that proprietorship firms cannot file independently, but the individual proprietor can file in his/her own name on behalf of the proprietorship.
-
Pawan Dubey v. J.B.K. Developers (NCLT):
Clarified that if a proprietorship files in its own name without disclosing the proprietor, it is not maintainable.
⚠ Implication:
| Proprietorship Firm | ✅ Cannot sue or be sued as a person under IBC |
|---|---|
| Proprietor (Individual) | ✅ Can initiate proceedings under IBC, representing the firm |
No comments:
Post a Comment